What Is a Section 44 Report in Canada?
A section 44 report is an officer’s written opinion, under IRPA s.44(1), that a permanent resident or foreign national in Canada is inadmissible, with the facts behind it. The Minister’s delegate reviews it and may refer it to the Immigration Division for a hearing or, in some cases, make a removal order. The report itself is not a conviction or a removal order.
ENF 5
IRCC’s manual for officers writing 44(1) reports
ENF 6
IRCC’s manual for the s.44(2) review by the Minister’s delegate
IRPR s.228
The cases where a removal order can be made without a hearing
IRPA s.45
What the Immigration Division may decide at a hearing
These are the published texts behind each stage. The IRPA s.44 page shows the full section.
What is a section 44 report, and who writes it?
IRPA s.44(1) says an officer who is of the opinion that a permanent resident or a foreign national in Canada is inadmissible “may prepare a report setting out the relevant facts”. The report “shall be transmitted to the Minister”. It records the officer’s opinion and the facts supporting it.
It is not a finding by a judge or a tribunal, and nothing in s.44(1) requires a hearing before it is written. Reports are prepared by officers designated under the Act, in practice officers of the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) and of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC).
The word “may” makes writing a report a discretionary step, not an automatic one, although IRCC’s manual tells officers that the courts have found this discretion very limited. IRCC publishes its guidance for officers on this step in the enforcement manual ENF 5, Writing 44(1) Reports.
The rule
A section 44 report is a written report by an immigration or border officer setting out the officer’s opinion that you are inadmissible to Canada.
What does a section 44 report not mean?
- Not a conviction
- A report is an administrative document about admissibility. It does not charge you with a crime, and no court has made a finding against you because a report exists.
- Not a removal order
- A removal order is made later, either by the Immigration Division under IRPA s.45 or by the Minister in the circumstances prescribed by IRPR s.228. A report is the step that can lead there.
- Not an immediate loss of status
- A permanent resident loses status when a removal order made against them comes into force (IRPA s.46(1)(c)), not when a report is written.
- Not the same as being refused entry
- Being turned around at a port of entry, allowed to withdraw an application to enter, or refused a visa are different outcomes with different consequences from a s.44 report.
What happens after a report is written?
The sequence below is the statutory path. Timing varies widely with the ground and the circumstances.
The report goes to the Minister
IRPA s.44(1) provides that the report shall be transmitted to the Minister. It sets out the relevant facts and the inadmissibility ground the officer believes applies.
IRPA s.44(1)
A delegated officer reviews it
Under s.44(2) the question is whether the report is well founded, which is a review of the report rather than a fresh hearing. The reviewer is generally called the Minister’s delegate, and ENF 6 describes the delegate’s discretion as limited.
ENF 6
Referral, or a removal order without a hearing
A well-founded report may be referred to the Immigration Division for an admissibility hearing. For a permanent resident reported solely under the s.28 residency obligation, and for a foreign national in the circumstances prescribed by IRPR s.228, the Minister may make a removal order instead.
IRPA s.44(2)
The admissibility hearing
The Immigration Division decides under IRPA s.45. It may recognize the right to enter of a citizen, a person registered under the Indian Act or a permanent resident, or grant status to a foreign national who meets the Act’s requirements. It may also authorize entry for further examination, or make the applicable removal order. Under IRPA s.167(1), you may be represented by legal or other counsel at your own expense.
IRPA s.45
If a removal order is made
A removal order is enforceable once it has come into force and is not stayed (IRPA s.48(1)). A permanent resident loses that status when a removal order made against them comes into force (IRPA s.46(1)(c)). Appeal rights, where they exist, are in IRPA s.63 and are limited by s.64.
IRPA s.48(1)
Which removal order follows a report?
Where the Regulations allow the Minister to decide, no hearing is held: IRPR s.228 lists those prescribed circumstances and fixes the type of order that follows. Where the Immigration Division makes the order, IRPR s.229 sets out which type applies to which ground.
The three order types have very different consequences for coming back. Removal orders and coming back to Canada covers each one.
| Ground in the report | Order made | Section |
|---|---|---|
| Criminality or serious criminality based on a conviction in Canada (IRPA s.36(1)(a) or (2)(a)) | Deportation order | IRPR s.228(1) |
| Misrepresentation under IRPA s.40(1)(c) | Deportation order | IRPR s.228(1) |
| Several failures to comply with the Act under s.41 | Exclusion order | IRPR s.228(1) |
| A permanent resident reported only for failing the residency obligation | Departure order, the least restrictive of the three | IRPR s.228(2) |
Are permanent residents and foreign nationals treated differently?
Permanent residents:
- A well-founded report is generally referred to the Immigration Division. The one exception in s.44(2) is a permanent resident inadmissible solely for failing the residency obligation under s.28, where the Minister may make the removal order.
- A permanent resident or a protected person may appeal a removal order to the Immigration Appeal Division under IRPA s.63(3), whether the order was made under s.44(2) or at an admissibility hearing.
- IRPA s.64 removes that appeal for security, violating human or international rights, sanctions, serious criminality or organized criminality. For s.64, serious criminality means a crime punished in Canada by a term of imprisonment of at least six months, or an offence described in IRPA s.36(1)(b) or (c).
Foreign nationals:
- Section 44(2) allows a removal order to be made without an admissibility hearing in the circumstances IRPR s.228 sets out. Many common grounds sit on that list, so a hearing is not the default for every foreign national.
- A foreign national who holds a permanent resident visa may appeal a removal order to the Immigration Appeal Division under IRPA s.63(2). Other foreign nationals generally have no appeal to that Division, though other legal avenues may exist.
- Conditions, including a deposit or a guarantee, may be imposed on a person who is the subject of a report, a hearing, or a removal order under IRPA s.44(3).
Which free tool checks your own case?
- Criminal EquivalencyHow foreign offences line up with Canadian law
- Rehabilitation CalculatorDeemed rehabilitation and eligibility dates (IRPA s.36)
Free, with no account. What you enter in a tool stays in your browser.
What do people ask?
What is a section 44 report?
A section 44 report is a written report in which an immigration or border officer states the opinion that a permanent resident or foreign national in Canada is inadmissible, with the facts behind it. IRPA s.44(1) says the report "shall be transmitted to the Minister." It is an administrative step, not a criminal charge and not a removal order. The IRPA s.44 page shows the full section.
What is the difference between a section 44(1) report and section 44(2)?
Section 44(1) is the report itself: an officer writes down the opinion that you are inadmissible. Section 44(2) is the review that follows: if the Minister, in practice a delegated officer, finds the report well founded, the report may be referred to the Immigration Division for an admissibility hearing, or a removal order may be made in cases the Regulations prescribe. IRPR s.228 lists those cases.
Does a section 44 report mean deportation?
No, a report does not by itself remove anyone. IRPA s.44(2) says a well-founded report "may" be referred to a hearing, or a removal order may be made in the cases IRPR s.228 prescribes. If an order is made, it can be a departure, exclusion or deportation order, depending on the ground, and each has different rules for coming back. The Removal Orders Explained guide compares all three.
What grounds can a section 44 inadmissibility report be based on?
The report names the inadmissibility ground the officer believes applies, taken from IRPA ss.34 to 42. The grounds are security, human or international rights violations, sanctions, serious criminality, criminality, transborder criminality, organized criminality, health, financial reasons, misrepresentation, cessation of refugee protection, non-compliance with the Act and an inadmissible family member. A permanent resident who fails the residency obligation is reported under s.41. The Admissibility Explorer walks through each ground.
Who writes a section 44 report, IRCC or CBSA?
Both can. The report is written by an officer designated under IRPA, and in practice these are officers of the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) and of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC). The report then goes to the Minister, and a delegated officer, usually called the Minister's delegate, does the s.44(2) review. IRCC's enforcement manuals ENF 5 and ENF 6 describe both steps for officers.
Can I respond to a section 44 report?
It depends on the stage, because section 44 sets out no submissions procedure of its own. IRCC's manual ENF 5 says that when an officer calls a person to an interview before writing a report, the officer explains its purpose so the person can make meaningful submissions. At an admissibility hearing before the Immigration Division, IRPA s.167(1) lets you be represented by counsel at your own expense. What you can usefully put forward depends on your facts, so take the report to a licensed immigration lawyer or a College-regulated consultant.
Do permanent residents always get an admissibility hearing?
Generally yes, with one exception written into IRPA s.44(2). A permanent resident reported only for failing the residency obligation under s.28 can receive a removal order from the Minister's delegate without a hearing, and IRPR s.228(2) makes it a departure order. Permanent residents can appeal a removal order to the Immigration Appeal Division under IRPA s.63(3), unless IRPA s.64 bars the appeal.
Part of:Criminal record
- Deported from Canada: Can You Come Back?
- Can You Enter Canada with a DUI?
- US Criminal Record & Canada: Complete Master Guide

The textbook on this subject
Volume 1: Entering Canada $79
Six IRPA inadmissibility grounds (s.36 and s.38 to s.42), explained with the official text cited.
Follow on Facebook to hear when the library opens (opens in a new tab)Official sources
This page is based on law and policy published by the Government of Canada.
