California PC 1203.4 and Entering Canada

On its own, a PC 1203.4 dismissal does not clear you for Canada. It leaves the conviction in place under California law, and Canada recognizes foreign relief only when it erases a conviction like a record suspension. A favourable internal IRCC staff guide, public only through an access-to-information release, is not law and does not bind the border officer. Deemed rehabilitation, Criminal Rehabilitation or a TRP gives a real answer.

See which IRPA sections apply with the Admissibility Explorer

Last verified: November 2026

$246.25
IRCC’s Criminal Rehabilitation fee for non-serious criminality
$1,231
IRCC’s Criminal Rehabilitation fee for serious criminality
$246.25
IRCC’s Temporary Resident Permit fee
Over a year
How long IRCC says rehabilitation applications can take

IRCC sets these fees. The Fee Calculator shows each one.

What does a PC 1203.4 dismissal do, and what does it not do?

Under California Penal Code section 1203.4, a person who has fulfilled the conditions of probation (or been discharged from probation early) may petition the court to:

Withdraw their guilty plea (or plea of nolo contendere).
Enter a plea of not guilty.
Have the accusation or information dismissed.

The statute then takes most of it back. These limits are written into PC 1203.4 itself:

The conviction "may be pleaded and proved and shall have the same effect as if probation had not been granted" in any later prosecution. It remains a usable prior.
The order "does not relieve" you of the duty to disclose the conviction when applying for public office, state or local licensure, or contracting with the California State Lottery Commission.
The dismissal "does not permit a person to own, possess, or have custody or control of a firearm". The California firearm prohibition survives.
The dismissal "does not permit a person prohibited from holding public office as a result of that conviction to hold public office".

PC 1203.4 is rehabilitative relief. It rewards completed probation, but it keeps the conviction alive for several purposes. United States immigration authorities also treat a conviction dismissed under a state rehabilitative statute as a conviction (USCIS Policy Manual, volume 12, part F, chapter 2).

How does Canada assess foreign relief?

Canadian inadmissibility for foreign convictions runs through IRPA section 36. The statute gives relief for Canadian record suspensions and acquittals, but says nothing about foreign expungements.

Those are assessed under principles from the Federal Court of Appeal in Canada (MCI) v Saini, 2001 FCA 311: a foreign discharge or pardon is recognized only if the foreign legal system is similar to Canada's, the aim, content and effect of the foreign law are similar to Canadian law, and there is no valid reason to refuse recognition. Recognition is the exception, and the burden is on you.

A dismissal that leaves the conviction pleadable as a prior, keeps disclosure duties, and preserves the firearm ban does not erase the conviction. It recognizes rehabilitation.

IRCC's manual ENF 1, Inadmissibility, makes a related point from the case law: a foreign legal procedure that is not equivalent to an absolute or conditional discharge is not treated as one in Canada, and the conviction remains.

The Federal Court has also upheld an officer's refusal to recognize a foreign expungement that the foreign court had to grant once a set time had passed (see Havlikova v Canada, 2018 FC 691, on the Czech regime). And IRCC's public rehabilitation guidance tells travellers that charges withdrawn or dismissed outside Canada mean you "may be inadmissible". None of this makes recognition of a 1203.4 dismissal impossible. It makes it discretionary and contestable.

The rule

Canadian law recognizes foreign relief only where its effect is to erase the conviction, the way a Canadian record suspension does.

IRCC manual ENF 3, part 10.9Verify on canada.ca

Where does the “consulate recognition” claim come from?

The widely repeated claim that Canada treats a PC 1203.4 dismissal as equivalent to a record suspension traces to the United States Criminality Assessment Guide, an internal reference guide that IRCC's New York office wrote, in consultation with IRCC Los Angeles, to help staff triage criminal rehabilitation applications consistently.

IRCC has not published it: the public copy was released under access to information and is hosted on a Canadian law firm's website, not an official one. That site dates the guide 2021, while a companion IRCC New York report released under the Access to Information Act (file A-2022-61809) says IRCC New York created and distributed it in 2019. It is not law and does not bind an officer.

The released documents show what it is and what it is not:

It is internal guidance, not law. It was created to share research among IRCC staff processing rehabilitation applications. It does not amend IRPA, and no statute or regulation recognizes 1203.4 relief.
IRCC's own description is hedged. IRCC New York's reporting describes state relief mechanisms as dispositions that "may or may not equate to a records suspension or conditional discharge in Canada". Case by case, not automatic.
It does not bind the border. A CBSA officer at a port of entry makes their own admissibility determination. Officers are not required to apply an internal visa-office triage guide.
The favourable reading is narrow. Even where the guide's approach is applied, it concerns a single dismissed conviction with a clean record otherwise. Multiple offences, serious offences, or anything else on your record ends the favourable analysis.

What happens at the border with a 1203.4 dismissal?

When you arrive at a Canadian port of entry with a 1203.4 dismissed conviction, an officer can ask about the original conviction, and IRPA s.16(1) requires a truthful answer.

One officer's favourable decision does not bind the next. Each entry is a fresh determination.

Which routes does IRPA provide?

Deemed rehabilitation: For a single, non-serious conviction (Canadian equivalent punishable by a maximum under 10 years), you may be deemed rehabilitated once 10 years have passed since the full sentence, including probation, was completed. This flows from IRPA s.36(3)(c) and IRPR s.18. No application is filed, and an officer checks the conditions.
Criminal rehabilitation: Available 5 years after sentence completion. An application that removes the ground of inadmissibility if approved. Your 1203.4 dismissal is supporting evidence of rehabilitation inside this application, which is the context the IRCC assessment guide was written for.
Temporary resident permit (TRP): For travel before you qualify for the above, an officer can issue a TRP where your reasons to enter outweigh the risk.

If your conviction is from another state, the same framework applies: that state's relief is measured against the same test, and the rehabilitation routes work the same way. See our expunged record and Canada entry guide.

Which free tool checks your own case?

Free, with no account. What you enter in a tool stays in your browser.

What do people ask?

Does a California PC 1203.4 dismissal make me admissible to Canada?

Not by itself. The dismissal does not erase the conviction under California law, and Canadian law only recognizes foreign relief whose effect is to erase it. IRCC's manual ENF 3 says relief that merely recognizes rehabilitation leaves the person inadmissible, with an application for rehabilitation as the route. An officer decides each case. Our Criminal Rehabilitation page explains that application.

Is a PC 1203.4 dismissal the same as an expungement?

No. Under the statute, the conviction can still be pleaded and proved as a prior offence, must still be disclosed for public office or state licensure, and the firearm ban remains. IRCC's manual ENF 3 asks whether foreign relief erases the conviction or merely recognizes that rehabilitation has taken place. A 1203.4 dismissal leaves the conviction in place for those purposes. Our Expunged Record guide covers other states.

What about the Canadian consulate guide that recognizes 1203.4 dismissals?

It is internal guidance, not law. IRCC New York wrote the United States Criminality Assessment Guide to help staff triage criminal rehabilitation applications. The public copy was released under access to information and sits on a law firm's website, not an official one. That site dates the guide 2021, while a companion IRCC New York report released under the Access to Information Act (file A-2022-61809) says IRCC New York created and distributed it in 2019. It does not bind CBSA officers at the border. It matters most inside a rehabilitation or opinion process at a visa office, where your dismissal is helpful evidence. Our Criminal Rehabilitation page explains that process.

I was told at the border years ago that my 1203.4 dismissal was fine. Am I safe now?

Not necessarily, because one officer's favourable decision does not bind the next. Each entry is a fresh determination. If you travel often, the routes the law provides are deemed rehabilitation if the timing fits, or an approved Criminal Rehabilitation. A legal opinion letter you carry can set out your case for the officer. Our Deemed Rehabilitation guide shows how the 10-year timing works.

How long until deemed or criminal rehabilitation applies?

For a single conviction whose Canadian equivalent carries a maximum under 10 years, deemed rehabilitation may apply 10 years after the full sentence, including probation, was completed (IRPR s.18). Criminal Rehabilitation can be requested 5 years after the sentence ends and removes the ground of inadmissibility if approved. A DUI committed on or after December 18, 2018 carries a 10-year maximum, which changes the answer. Our DUI guide explains that case.

Does PC 1203.4 relief help at all, then?

Yes, as evidence. Inside a Criminal Rehabilitation application or a legal opinion, the dismissal shows completed probation, judicial recognition of rehabilitation and years of clean record. It can also persuade an individual border officer. What it cannot safely do is replace the legal mechanisms that remove inadmissibility under IRPA s.36(3)(c). Our Criminal Rehabilitation page explains that application.

What should I bring to the Canadian border with a 1203.4 dismissal?

Bring the certified 1203.4 court order, the complete court record and your California DOJ record. The court record should show the original charge, disposition, sentence, probation terms and proof that every condition was completed. Answer truthfully if asked about convictions, because misrepresentation under IRPA s.40 is a separate ground of inadmissibility that lasts five years. Our Admissibility Explorer shows which rules apply to you.

Part of:Criminal record

Official sources

This page is based on law and policy published by the Government of Canada.